The Role of a Batterer’s Class in a California Domestic Violence Criminal Threats Conviction

Domestic violence, under California law, exists when a crime is committed against an individual by that individual’s intimate partner. Intimate partners include persons who are either heterosexual or homosexual and are dating, formerly dated, married, divorced, living together or have children together. This means that if an individual threatens his or her intimate partner, the charge will be prosecuted as a domestic abuse offense.

“Criminal threats” may be charged when an individual, either in person, in writing or through a third person, threatens to commit a crime against his or her intimate partner that would result in serious bodily injury or death to that partner if the crime was committed. The fact that the accused didn’t actually intend to commit the crime will not serve as a defense to this crime if the partner reasonably feared for his or her safety upon receipt of the threat.

California D.V. law requires that a defendant who is placed on probation for making a criminal threat against his or her intimate partner attend a batterer’s class. The offender will be required to attend class for a two-hour period at least once a week for one year. These classes are designed to help people convicted of intimate partner abuse learn to better control their anger.

Batterer’s classes are sensitive to sexual orientation, culture and ethnicity, and are conducted in either all female or all male settings. They are available to people of all economic classes. California regulates each class’s program to make sure that each class covers the same material regardless of its location in the state. Classes address the dynamics of power and control, socialization, gender roles, the nature of violence and the effects of abuse on children and others. Included in these broad topics are discussions about different types of abuse, which includes emotional, physical and sexual abuse, economic manipulation or control, threatening a partner, the destruction of property and other acts that affect the well-being and safety of the family.

Teaching a person convicted of a domestic violence crime to walk away from a potentially violent situation is the goal of this type of counseling. In order to achieve this objective, the facilitators encourage their students to examine their lives to gain a deeper understanding about why they need to be in control. If successful, the offender learns that he or she cannot control a relationship through violence or intimidation and has further learned effective ways to communicate and restore balance within his or her intimate relationship.

The defendant’s progress will be monitored by the court and will be considered unsatisfactory if the defendant either blames his or her partner for the abuse or in any other way attempts to shift his or her personal responsibility. When this type of denial or attitude exists, the class leader will confront the individual who has taken such a stance and will refute his or her justification for threatening or intimidating his or her intimate partner. The offender will also receive information about the destructive impact that domestic abuse has on self-esteem and on children who are either victims of or witnesses to such abuse.

The caring criminal defense lawyers at The Kavinoky Law Firm understand that attending a batterer’s program may be one of the most difficult conditions of probation for some of their clients to fulfill. With their compassion and discretion, they will make this difficult time a little easier. A skilled defense attorney can answer any questions about a California criminal threats charge during a free consultation.

Domestic battery, often known as “spousal abuse” or “spousal battery,” is a domestic violence offense in California that applies to intimate partners. “Intimate partners” is a term that covers a wide range of relationships – people of the opposite gender or same sex who are married, divorced, living together, have children in common, and who are dating or formerly dated.

Domestic battery is referred to as a “wobbler” offense, meaning it can be charged as either a misdemeanor or a felony depending on the facts of the case. Battery can be charged any time a person willfully and unlawfully uses force or violence upon an intimate partner. The offense is typically charged as a misdemeanor and carries a maximum penalty of a one year jail sentence and a $2,000 fine. This charge can be brought against a defendant even if he or she used the slightest force or engaged in any unwanted touching. However, in cases of serious bodily injury, such as loss of consciousness, broken bones, or a concussion, the individual will likely face felony charges punishable by a maximum of four years in state prison.

With such severe consequences, a battery charge is no joke. That is why it is imperative for the accused to hire an attorney who is knowledgeable not only with respect to California domestic abuse crimes, but with the types of evidentiary issues that frequently arise during these types of trials. The experienced criminal defense lawyers at The Kavinoky Law Firm have successfully defended countless individuals in battery cases because they receive ongoing training and education about intimate partner abuse cases and the issues that commonly surround these types of cases. They know how to argue for admission or exclusion of hearsay and 911 evidence to provide the most effective defense for their clients.

“Hearsay” is a legal term that refers to statements that were made out of court that are later offered in court as evidence of their truth. Although hearsay evidence is generally inadmissible in criminal proceedings, there are exceptions to that rule, and intimate partner violence cases are one of those exceptions.

Under California law, hearsay statements, including 911 telephone calls, are relevant in domestic abuse cases. This exception admits into evidence statements made by the complaining witness at the time when he or she was experiencing or witnessing the violent act or acts that are the subject of the case. The rationale behind this exception is that the spontaneity of such statements and the lack of opportunity for reflection and deliberate fabrication provide an adequate guarantee of their trustworthiness. Clearly this isn’t the case in reality, as many 911 calls have been placed under false pretenses and based on underlying motives such as anger, revenge and jealousy. Nonetheless, these statements are admissible into evidence and, in a vigorous effort to convict the defendant, the prosecutor will seek to have the investigating officer read the alleged victim’s statements to the jury and will also ask the judge to play the recorded 911 call for the jury. However, even the exceptions have exceptions, which is why it is so important to have professional legal representation that is familiar with this area of the law.

Because of the highly complex and technical rules (and exceptions to those rules) that come into play in a California intimate partner abuse case, having a skilled and qualified defense lawyer who knows how to exclude or downplay this type of evidence is critical. The attorneys at The Kavinoky Law Firm have both the knowledge and experience to aggressively tackle any issue that may arise in a battery case. Whether the allegation stems from an intense, emotional dispute that took a turn for the worse, from a false report, or from a simple mistake, professional guidance can help ease a difficult situation. When things are at their worst, the attorneys from The Kavinoky Law Firm are at their best! Click here for a free consultation and for the best representation.

When the police arrive

When someone is either directly involved in or witnesses a domestic violence situation and calls the police or 911, police officers will be dispatched to the scene. Before the officers even begin asking questions, they will likely make two assumptions – first, if a man and a woman are present, it was the woman who was abused and second, that whoever placed the call to the police is the “victim” and the other partner is the “abuser, batterer or offender”. Once they have made those assumptions, they will begin questioning the partners in the attempt to verify their assumptions. During this process, it is best to remain silent until an attorney is present.

In California, intimate partner abuse is taken very seriously. When the police are called to investigate a charge of domestic abuse, it is likely that someone will be arrested. Even if the individual who first called the police changes his or her mind and tells the officers that the call shouldn’t have been placed, it will not matter. Once that first call is made and the police are involved, the case takes on a life of its own and it is only the prosecuting agency and the judge who have any control over the charges. The partner who made the call cannot tell the police that he or she doesn’t wish to “press charges” or that he or she wants to “drop the charges” because that individual gave up control of the situation as soon as the police were called.

Once the police arrive they will begin asking questions to uncover the chain of events that led to the call for their help. They will most likely question each partner (and any witnesses who are present) individually and out of the presence of the other(s) to make sure that each party tells his or her side of the story. The officers will repeatedly ask the same questions in an effort in break the individual down to expose any lies or discrepancies in that individual’s account. It is generally impossible to talk one’s way out of this type of investigation and, therefore, one shouldn’t even try to do so. The best advice is to politely advise the police that an attorney must be present before questions will be answered. This is why it is imperative to contact a skilled criminal defense lawyer from The Kavinoky Law Firm immediately after the police are called to the scene.

Although it is difficult, it is critical that the partner being accused remains silent. It is human nature to try to defend oneself by explaining one’s actions, but it is essential not to reveal anything that may inadvertently be incriminating. The accused must not make any admissions, even if that means that he or she will be arrested, as one’s silence cannot be used against him or her in court.

In addition to questioning the parties, the police will conduct a visual sweep of the scene for obvious evidence of domestic violence (holes in the wall, broken furniture, visible injuries, etc.). They will also seek to remove any firearms or other weapons from the home. The officers will also give information to the “victim” about restraining orders. It is in the best interests of the suspect to remain silent throughout this investigation and to simply let the officers do their jobs. Aside from insisting upon a criminal defense attorney, silence is the best policy.

Being accused of a domestic violence offense is scary and overwhelming. Contacting a compassionate yet aggressive attorney should be the first step in the process. An attorney from The Kavinoky Law Firm will not only help the accused navigate through the justice system with ease and understanding but will also provide the best representation available. Click here for a free consultation.

California is very strict with its child abuse offenders and holds people who place their children in dangerous situations accountable in the same manner as it does people who directly abuse their children. Child endangerment may be charged as a California domestic violence crime under one of two theories. In the first instance, a child endangerment charge may be filed when a child is a witness to domestic abuse between his or her parents. It is defined as the abuse that a child suffers while witnessing such an event. In the second instance, a child endangerment charge may be filed when one’s child is placed in a situation where he or she is likely to suffer a serious injury or death, regardless of whether the child actually suffers such an injury, when one permits or causes his or her child to be injured, or when once causes or permits his or her child to be in a situation where the child’s body or health may be endangered. This second area of prosecution has no bearing on whether domestic abuse was occurring in the home, but rather will be treated as a crime of domestic violence simply because the perpetrator was a parent of the child.

Child endangerment manifests itself in a number of ways and may be caused by physical abuse, emotional abuse or neglect. In effect, it is basically any reckless or negligent behavior on the part of a parent that places his or her child’s well-being in jeopardy. Child endangerment is an escalating problem, and the legislature is quick to respond as they continue to update laws, not only to punish offenders with stricter penalties, but to crack down on parents by defining more ways to hold them criminally responsible for their negligent and/or reckless behavior.

Some of the most commonly prosecuted D.V. child endangerment charges include parents driving under the influence of drugs and/or alcohol with their children in the car, parents getting drunk or high while their children are home with no additional supervision, parents entrusting their children to unfit caregivers, parents exposing their children to “meth labs” or other places that engage in illegal or “adult only” activities, parents leaving their children who are too young to care for themselves home with no adult supervision, and parents who expose their children to pornography, sexual activity, and unsecured firearms.

An individual facing child endangerment charges will almost always face the following penalties and, depending on whether an additional intimate partner abuse crime is filed, may face even more. If convicted of child endangerment as a misdemeanor, the defendant faces up to one year in jail, and if convicted of the charge as a felony, the defendant faces two, four or six years in the state prison. In addition to jail or prison time, if a convicted offender is placed on probation, he or she will be on probation for at least four years, will have a criminal protective order issued against him or her to protect his or her child from further abuse, will be required to successfully complete at least one year in a child abuser’s treatment counseling program and, if drugs or alcohol were involved in the alleged offense, the defendant will also be required to abstain from using alcohol or drugs while on probation, will be subject to random testing and may additionally be required to complete a drug and/or alcohol dependency program.

Defense Attorneys for Child Abuse Law

The experienced criminal defense lawyers at the Kavinoky Law Firm specialize in California domestic violence crimes and in successfully defending those individuals charged with child-related offenses. They pride themselves on keeping current in this special area of the law and on the many evidentiary issues and defenses that coincide with DV offenses. To speak to an attorney about a child endangerment charge, click here for a free consultation.

Infliction of injury, more commonly called “spousal abuse,” is a California domestic violence crime that applies to intimate partners. These partners may be married or divorced, living together or formerly living together or have children in common. The laws apply to both heterosexual couples and same-sex partnerships. If an individual willfully inflicts any injury, no matter how minor, upon the body of an intimate partner, he or she can be charged with a felony, punishable by up to four years in prison and a fine of up to $6,000.

Even though an individual faces up to four years in prison for committing this crime, an experienced criminal defense lawyer may arrange it so that his or her client never spends a day in a cell. The outstanding attorneys at The Kavinoky Law Firm specialize in California domestic abuse law. They know the intricacies involved in sentencing, and as a result, can effectively fight to keep their clients out of jail or prison.

Alternative sentencing is just that – an alternative to incarceration. When properly utilized, alternative sentencing can be even more effective than jail or prison, as it usually has some rehabilitative element to it, as opposed to straight punishment. When an individual is rehabilitated, it not only benefits that particular person, but his or her family, the courts and society as a whole.

There are several factors that a judge may consider when hearing a defense attorney’s recommendation for alternative sentencing. An attorney will usually address any mitigating or extenuating circumstances that were involved in the defendant’s case, whether alcohol or drugs played a role in the charged incident and whether the accused suffers from mental illness. Because every person and every case is different, an experienced lawyer will know what facts and circumstances are relevant to his or her client’s case and which are likely to persuade a judge that alternative sentencing is appropriate.

In an infliction of injury case, there are several options that may be imposed as an alternative to jail or prison time. The attorneys at The Kavinoky Law Firm will aggressively advocate on behalf of their clients to ensure that alternative sentencing is imposed when appropriate. These options include probation, either formal or informal, house arrest, electronic monitoring, community service or labor, individual or group therapy for issues dealing with drugs, alcohol and/or other addictive behaviors, and making restitution to the victim when possible. Although this list is not exhaustive, it includes the most popular alternatives to serving time.

When arrested on an infliction of injury charge, the defendant faces life-changing consequences. His or her family, reputation, career and freedom are all in jeopardy, especially if sentenced to a significant jail or prison term. Unfortunately, many attorneys don’t know that alternative sentencing is available. Speaking with a qualified criminal defense lawyer is the safest way to ensure that the possibility of losing it all doesn’t become a reality. The attorneys at The Kavinoky Law Firm receive ongoing education and training in intimate partner abuse law and its penalties, keeping them ahead of the competition. Their reputation for treating their clients with compassion and respect is only surpassed by their success rate. One’s freedom is too important to trust to an inexperienced attorney. Click here for a free consultation and for the best representation.

• Article Library

The Possible Consequences of Domestic Violence in California

Domestic violence is a “wobbler” crime in California, and it can be charged and prosecuted either as a misdemeanor or a felony. A Sacramento criminal attorney can explain the likely consequences of a particular domestic violence charge best, because this requires an understanding of how the local and state statutes and penal codes determine the gravity of the offense and appropriate punishment.

In general, California law establishes the baseline consequences for a domestic violence conviction. If convicted for a misdemeanor, the potential sentence includes minimum of a 52-week domestic violence course with behavior counseling, 40 hours of community service, a “No Contact Order” with the victim, and several different fines. Many times the prosecutor will not try to get the maximum fine and many judges will not opt for more than a month of jail time, though a maximum of a year is possible. In many cases, alternate sentences that increase the financial cost but eliminate jail time in favor of a work program are possible.

A felony conviction entails a similar domestic violence program, more community service, the same no contact order, significantly higher fines, and a minimum jail sentence of three months. Depending on the severity, this can take the form of a year or more in prison, or something less serious such as supervised probation. In either case, local statutes leave a wide range of sentences for the prosecution and the judge to choose from depending on all the related factors.

No matter what your circumstance, whether you are a victim of domestic violence or have been charged with the crime, you need a Sacramento criminal attorney immediately. The right attorney can help protect you, help you get the counseling or therapy you need, and see that local and California laws are executed fairly for the sake of the victim and the accused .The end goal is the appropriate sentence so that both people can lead better, safer lives.

• Article Library

If you have been the victim domestic violence and want to press charges against your abuser but are afraid to do so, the first step you need to take is to reach out to a Los Angeles domestic violence attorney. Surprisingly, a Los Angeles criminal defense lawyer with domestic violence experience can often offer very sound advice as to your first steps depending on your circumstances. They will almost always include finding a way to make yourself safe from your abuser such as moving out.

You need to understand a few things about domestic violence. If you have been a victim, pressing charges may be emotionally and practically difficult, especially if the abuser is your spouse or the parent of your child. He or she may threaten you or attempt to prevent you from informing the police or testifying, which is illegal but can be quite coercive. And if the only evidence of the abuse is your word, the abuser’s defense lawyer will almost certainly attack your character in court, so you need to prepare to defend yourself despite your stressed emotional state. Once you have contacted a lawyer to begin preparing your legal charges, and moved out or done what you need to make yourself safe from the abuser, you should also call the police.

In dire circumstances, this should actually be your first step as the police should come and arrest the accused abuser and get him or her out of the house. They can also collect immediate evidence of the abuse at this point, or direct you to a police medical examiner to look for physical or emotional signs of abuse. This is important because this evidence will service as the primary foundation for your case and will make it more difficult for a Los Angeles criminal defense lawyer to weaken the case by assaulting your character. You will have to tell the police you want to press charges, and it can be difficult to persevere when put on the spot about having your partner tried for abuse. But in the end, nobody should live in fear of abuse, least of all children, so you will find you are doing the right thing to seek legal help and press domestic abuse charges.

• Article Library
• Crack Cocaine Cases

Domestic violence cases will be more difficult to prosecute following a U.S. Supreme Court decision that will make it harder for prosecutors to use out-of-court statements as evidence against defendants.

The court ruled that allowing a murder victim’s earlier reports to police to be admitted as evidence denies the suspect’s right to confront his accuser unless the killing was committed to silence the accuser.

The court ruled 6-3 to overturn the murder conviction of a Los Angeles man who shot and killed his girlfriend. The man claimed the killing was done in self-defense but was convicted after a police officer testified that the woman had reported that the man threatened her life.

Until 2004, prosecutors could introduce statements made by victims who were unable or unwilling to testify, including statements made to police.  Police can now testify about what they witnessed, but cannot repeat statements made by the victim unless prosecutors can prove that the victim was killed in order to silence him/her.

However, proving that a killing occurred to silence the victim is extremely difficult. The court’s ruling will also impact domestic violence cases where the victim is available to testify but unwilling to do so.

To learn more about prosecution and defenses to California domestic violence cases, contact a skilled defense lawyer from The Kavinoky Law Firm today for a free consultation