Prior convictions and their effect on a California domestic violence stalking case
Stalking will be charged when an individual follows or harasses and threatens another with the intent to place that person in fear. In and of itself, it is not a domestic violence crime. However, if an individual follows or harasses and threatens his or her intimate partner with the intent to place that partner in fear, that individual will be charged with stalking as a domestic abuse crime. California’s domestic violence laws apply to all crimes where the defendant and the alleged victim are intimate partners. Intimate partners are those who are married or divorced, dating or formerly dating, living together or those who have children together. These laws apply to both heterosexual and homosexual partners.
Depending on the circumstances, a stalking charge can be filed as either a misdemeanor, punishable by up to one year in the county jail and/or a maximum $1,000 fine or as a felony, punishable by up to one year in the state prison. The law imposes no mandatory imprisonment for this charge, absent certain aggravating factors. A skilled criminal defense lawyer may, therefore, be able to persuade the court to impose probation conditions that will keep his or her client out of jail or prison. If, however, the accused has specific prior convictions on his or her record, he or she will likely face at least two and as many as five years in the state prison. The outstanding attorneys at the Kavinoky Law Firm will aggressively defend their clients and will argue against mandatory imprisonment. Because of their deep understanding of intimate partner abuse crimes, they know what facts and circumstances may help convince a court that alternative sentencing would be more appropriate.
When a defendant convicted on a D.V. stalking charge has also been previously convicted of felony stalking, he or she faces imprisonment in the state prison for two, three or five years, depending on the circumstances of both offenses. When a defendant convicted of intimate partner stalking also has prior convictions for infliction of injury, violation of a court order or criminal threats, he or she may be punished by the same one-year jail sentence with or without the $1,000 fine, by the same one-year prison sentence or, depending on the circumstances of the pending case and of the prior conviction(s), will face two, three or five years in the state prison. An attorney who is well versed with the laws surrounding stalking and intimate partner violence knows which arguments to make to help keep these penalties to a minimum.
Prior convictions not only affect sentencing, but also may unfortunately affect the outcome of the defendant’s trial. California allows in evidence of a defendant’s prior domestic violence convictions in a pending D.V. case even though prior convictions are excluded in most other types of criminal cases. The reason that this type of evidence is usually excluded is because a jury is likely to conclude that if the accused “did it before” he or she was “likely to do it again,” relying on old evidence instead of the evidence presented in the open case.
Clearly, prior convictions raise a host of issues that otherwise don’t exist in a first-time offender’s stalking case. This is another reason why it is critical that the accused hires a qualified defense lawyer who specializes in domestic abuse charges and therefore understands the complex and technical rules that are involved with these types of cases. The unparalleled attorneys at the Kavinoky Law Firm have successfully defended countless individuals who were accused of stalking their intimate partners. They receive ongoing training and education in domestic violence law, which is directly responsible for their outstanding results. Click here for a free consultation and for the best representation.
